Crystal Palace Manager Reflects on Goalless Draw with Everton and the Need for a Replay

Crystal Palace manager Roy Hodgson expressed his disappointment following a goalless draw with Everton at Selhurst Park, the opening fixture of the FA Cup third round. Despite both teams’ solid defensive displays, the match ended without a winner, setting up an unwanted replay in two weeks’ time at Goodison Park.

Everton had to play the final 11 minutes with 10 men after Dominic Calvert-Lewin was sent off for a studs-up challenge on Nathaniel Clyne, which was reviewed and confirmed by VAR. Hodgson admitted that neither side had been eager for the replay but acknowledged the outcome was largely due to the teams’ disciplined defences.

“Not ideal,” Hodgson remarked when asked about the replay. “Neither team wanted this, but that’s how it goes sometimes. Both sides were tough to break down, and we struggled to create clear-cut chances.”

When asked about Calvert-Lewin’s red card, Hodgson offered his sympathy, saying: “Sean [Dyche] and I were raised in a time when those types of challenges were part of the game and often went unpunished. However, if there’s intent behind the challenge, there’s always a risk of a red card. I don’t think there was any malice in Calvert-Lewin’s action. I do feel for him.”

The game also saw Matheus Franca, signed from Flamengo, make his first start for Palace before being substituted for Naourihou Ahamada in the 71st minute. Hodgson acknowledged that both players had been put in difficult positions, particularly against an Everton side known for its physicality.

“These aren’t the types of players who thrive in those conditions,” Hodgson explained. “They are technically gifted, but the game didn’t provide many opportunities for them to showcase their strengths. It will be valuable for them in the long run.”

Striker Odsonne Edouard, making his first appearance since a knee injury in December, also featured as a substitute. Hodgson noted that Edouard showed signs of rustiness but expressed optimism that the upcoming two-week break before the replay would help him regain full match fitness.

“It’s great to have Odsonne back,” Hodgson said. “He’s not at his best yet, but with more time to recover, he’ll only improve. We look forward to having him fit and ready for the replay.”