Ministers raise concerns about potential rule violations in Sue Gray’s planned shift to Labour, while opposition dismisses claims as “conspiracy theories.”
Sue Gray, the former civil servant who investigated Downing Street’s “partygate” scandal, faces scrutiny over her intended move to Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer’s office. Ministers, including Paymaster General Jeremy Quin, have suggested her transition might breach civil service rules.
Addressing Parliament, Mr Quin described the situation as “exceptional” and “unprecedented,” noting that Gray had not yet informed the Advisory Committee on Business Appointments (Acoba) as required. He highlighted key civil service rules that may apply, including impartiality, declaring outside interests, and seeking approval before job announcements. Quin called on Labour to release communications with Gray to ensure transparency.
Labour’s deputy leader Angela Rayner dismissed the allegations as baseless, accusing the Conservatives of being consumed by “conspiracy theories” propagated by Boris Johnson and his allies. “This debate reflects more on the Tories’ delusions than on anything substantial,” Rayner asserted.
Former Johnson ally Jacob Rees-Mogg argued that Gray’s plans undermine the concept of an independent civil service, claiming secretive dealings with the opposition erode her credibility. He also criticised how her work on “partygate” might now appear compromised.
The controversy follows Labour’s announcement of Gray as Sir Keir’s prospective chief of staff. While Johnson loyalists allege the move is politically motivated, Sir Keir has defended Gray’s integrity, emphasising her impartiality during the Downing Street investigation.
Sir Keir declined to specify when discussions with Gray began, only stating that it occurred after his former chief of staff departed in October. He reassured the public that Gray’s formal application to Acoba would adhere to established guidelines.
The Cabinet Office is reviewing the circumstances surrounding Gray’s resignation, while Acoba will assess whether a waiting period should precede her appointment. Though Acoba’s recommendations are advisory, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has the final say.
Meanwhile, ongoing investigations by the Privileges Committee into whether Johnson misled Parliament over lockdown parties could further complicate the political landscape. Allegations that Gray’s Labour move discredits her findings have added fuel to the debate, though Science Secretary Michelle Donelan vouched for her impartiality.
As the controversy unfolds, Gray remains poised to take on her new role pending official approval, with Sir Keir lauding her professional contributions and leadership capabilities.
